Darn. We Got the Security Obsessed, No Fun, Elite Olympics!
As the Olympics approach I am trying hard to get into the mood and share some of the fun and excitement. But I am having a problem. I can’t find the excitement. And no one seems to be having any fun, nor do many think they will even when the Olympics start. The evidence for this is everywhere – in the polls, in the bars, in the coffee shops, around the water coolers and in the media.
I supported the Olympics, in the government when the original decision was made to make an application, during the Vancouver vote and in the forums and discussions about it before and after the vote. I supported it because I believed it would showcase our beautiful city, inspire and perhaps shame us into really doing something to meet the needs of the people in the downtown east side, support our athletes and give us a chance a to celebrate our city and really have some fun. I believed that people in the province and the city would get to participate in the major events and that local businesses would have an opportunity to embrace and profit from the event. I really did believe that in Vancouver it could be the people’s Olympics.
Sadly, I was wrong. Ordinary people see it. They are surly and resentful about the whole thing. It shows in the frustration of many small business people, who have been banned from even mentioning the Olympics in their signs and promotions. They have in effect been told to butt out – these Olympics are not for them. Hard to imagine unless the money is everything. It shows in the herding of the homeless off the downtown streets and into the east side ghetto. This you can see with your own eyes if you go for a stroll on Hastings from Burrard to Main. Suddenly there are no homeless and few panhandlers until you get to Abbot, after which during the day the streets are a bee hive of homeless street people suffering from all kinds of maladies. That is where they have been pushed – out of sight, out of mind. Until its over.
Try as I might I don’t now feel like we are going to be having any fun. I don’t see that many feel they are going to be having any fun.
Mostly now I wonder why, and what went wrong. It will take time to figure it all out but already some of the main reasons are clear. They include:
1. The complete preoccupation with big money. Local business are being put under close watch and tight control because any reference to the Olympics by them might bring protests from the big money sponsors and advertiser. So there is no flexibility, no room for good will embraces by local businesses and no openings to get into the swing unless you have paid. This has turned the whole thing into a gross, vulgar event. How can there be a feeling of excitement when you have suppression of expression worthy of a police state? And why didn’t we have managers and politicians who pushed back on this?
2. The fixation on security. Security costs will be over $ 1 billion. Police and military will be everywhere. Ugly fences, barriers, and temporary structures secured by reminders of the Berlin wall are popping up all over. Already one should not be surprised to be challenged by a creepy security officer for being around some place that seems to have no security significance. We hear abut security zones and no go areas, but the descriptions are impossible to understanding. Its creepy. It’s no fun.
3. Constant reminders about congestion, traffic control, crowd management, pedestrian channeling and a whole host of other things that tell us only one thing – the Olympic managers are afraid of the people. We are their worst nightmare. We are told over and over again where we can’t go, what we can’t do, and what we can’t see. Mostly the message suggests that we should stay away. Especially seeing as how there will be so many rich and important people around. Our presence would take away from their enjoyment. That makes it pretty hard to have fun.
4. Pricing and availability of tickets. Somebody, somewhere in the whole Olympic organization lost their way a long time ago. Few local people got tickets. The one’s that did paid enormous prices. Now all we hear is that you can’t come, because you don’t have tickets and if you want one -say to the opening ceremonies you can get a poor seat for $2000. What are they thinking? How did they manage to stage opening ceremonies for example that are completely beyond the reach of any but the wealthiest. Didn’t anybody think about how to do this to be inclusive, not exclusive.
5. Irresponsible and needless spending. All of us hear that we have to accept cut backs, and that there is no money for housing, the poor, the arts, culture, schools, suffering communities outside Vancouver and on and on it goes. But no one ever seems to say no when it comes to Olympic spending. Need an improved highway – no problem – spend over $1 billion when much less would do. Need better transport form the airport – go ahead – spend a couple of billion and line the contractors pocket with a $400 million windfall over costs that no one will take responsibility for. Want a new building here, a fancy street boulevard there, a new temporary structure over there better built than any homeless shelter – go ahead – no problem if its for the Olympics. The city is literally dripping with dollars spent on extravagances that don’t make sense in these times of hardship. Have you seen the multi-million dollar refit of the ice rink at Robson Square? Have you heard about the $500 million dollar Olympic legacy retractable roof for BC Place? Meanwhile people who are suffering and in need and many important social priorities are being ignored. And the rural areas and communities in the interior are facing serious economic and social problems. The government’s response to them is that we hear your pain, but there’s no money. All of those has created a cognitive dissonance that helps explain the anger and the grumpiness.
6. Fun for the privileged but not for the people. The lack of availability and price of tickets are like a slap in the face to ordinary people. Perhaps it is true, as Vanoc claims, that this is just how big international events have to be these days. But if there is no other business model, than I think most people would prefer we stay out of the business. It is hard to believe that smart people could not have thought of someway to make local attendance easier and more affordable. And then we have the spectre of the Premier, Mayor, Cabinet Ministers, Liberal MLA’s and City Councillours voting themselves expensive taxpayer paid tickets to attend expensive events, ostensibly to encourage investment in our city. This is of course a silly rationale – no serious investor is going to be influenced by a free ticket, a steak and a bottle of fine wine with some petty local politician. As it is, seeing the way things have turned, these self serving politicians are seriously close to losing their social license to use and abuse our taxes and our city amenities.
7. “Help” for the homeless coming in the form of spin, temporary shelters, and security fences. This hardly needs elaboration. The sweeping claim made that a big benefit of the Olympics will be a resolution of the homeless problem because we cannot afford to have the world see this embarrassing scar on the heart of our city has turned out to be empty and meaningless. This is shameful and to most of us embarrassing.
8. And perhaps most of all, stiff, boring, no-fun leaders. Fun events are by definition populist events that resonate with mainstream residents. This is not happening. This Olympics reeks of elite privilege. Part of the explanation is that not one of the leading personalities has a populist bone in his or her body. They are all stiff, humourless, uneasy with people and impossible to imagine having a good time on their own, much less with real people. Gordon Campbell? A fun guy? I don’t think so. Gregor Robertson? Can you imagine having a genuine conversation with him? I doubt it. Furlong. Yikes, not someone you would even think about partying with. Ditto for Cabinet Members and City Councilours. The truth is there is no fun loving face of the Olympics. They are all constitutionally unable to have fun, palpably afraid of real people, and only comfortable with celebrities and the rich. And the leaders define the event. So this one is not going to be about people and having fun with them.
I still think the Olympics is a good idea. And I believe it will still come off as a well managed international spectacle. But handled differently it could also have been the people’s Olympics. It could have been a celebration. Sadly, however we are stuck with the no fun, elite Olympics. For most it will be two weeks discovering what it feels like to live in a police state run by humourless apparatchiks. That’s not the kind of Olympics I had hoped for. And it didn’t have to be this way. It is so much less than what it could have been, if we hadn’t ended up with these unimaginative, humourless, fear obsessed people in charge.